Chapter 91: Bad Character
Andrew came back in through the balcony window, Chandler and Joey following behind him.
The adult film conversation was over. The relevant facts had been established — Ursula had made it, Charlie had been in it, Phoebe hadn't known about it, and the question of whether and how to tell her was now the actual problem.
Andrew had his position: tell her. Bad things that had already happened didn't improve with concealment. Phoebe finding out eventually from someone other than her friends would be worse than finding out now, from people who cared about her.
Chandler had a counterargument: not today. Not at Monica's birthday party, with Jack and Judy here and the evening going well and Monica finally having the night she'd been planning for two weeks.
"After the party," Chandler said. "We find a normal day, we sit down with her, we explain the whole thing properly. Not in the middle of someone else's celebration."
Andrew thought about it. "What if Ursula says something tonight?"
"Then we manage it," Chandler said. "But we don't light the fuse ourselves."
It was, Andrew admitted internally, the more considered position. He'd brought Ursula partly to resolve the Chandler-and-Joey situation — their guilty avoidance of Phoebe over something that had nothing to do with Phoebe was a problem that needed solving, and meeting the actual person was the fastest way to solve it. The secondary effect of the evening being interesting had also been a factor, which was less defensible.
"You did that because you thought it would be entertaining," Joey said, reading this correctly.
"Partly," Andrew said.
Joey grabbed his face with both hands and squished his cheeks together in the specific way he expressed displeasure when words were insufficient. Andrew accepted this as earned.
"Okay," Andrew said, when released. "I'll go talk to her."
"Apologize," Joey said.
"That's what I said."
"Say it like you mean it," Joey added.
Phoebe was on the couch talking to Ursula when Andrew came over. The two of them had their heads together in a conversation that seemed warmer than he'd expected given their established history — Phoebe's expression had lost most of its initial stiffness, and Ursula was talking in the quieter register she occasionally deployed, the one that was closer to who she actually was.
He waited until there was a natural pause.
"Phoebe. Can I have a minute?"
She looked at him with the expression of someone who had already decided to accept an apology and was waiting to see how it was delivered.
He sat down across from her.
"I brought Ursula without thinking through how it would land," he said. "I knew it would be a surprise and I thought it would be interesting. I didn't think carefully enough about how you'd feel about it, or whether tonight was the right night for it." He paused. "That was thoughtless. I'm sorry."
Phoebe looked at him for a moment.
"You're actually sorry," she said, slightly surprised.
"Yes."
"You don't usually apologize like that."
"I'm working on it," he said.
Phoebe's expression did the thing it did when she was deciding to let something go — a small shift, the ledger closing. "Okay," she said. "Apology accepted."
She looked at him with the particular Phoebe quality of someone who saw more than she said. "She's not what I remembered," she said, quietly, about Ursula. "She seems — different tonight."
Andrew looked at Ursula, who had gotten up and was talking to Jean across the room with the easy, interested manner she could produce when she chose to.
"People are sometimes different than you expect," he said.
"Sometimes," Phoebe agreed, in a tone that communicated she was reserving judgment.
Andrew found Joey and Chandler in the kitchen.
"Done," he said.
"She accepted it?" Joey said.
"She accepted it."
Chandler was leaning against the counter. "Ursula gave her something," he said. "A gift for Monica, apparently. Phoebe put it in the coffee table drawer."
Andrew thought about this briefly. Ursula giving Monica's party a gift wasn't in the character profile he'd built for her, which was either evidence of the character being more complicated than he'd assumed, or evidence of something else.
He filed it and let it go. He'd been wrong about people before.
"After the party," he said. "We'll talk to Phoebe about the whole situation properly. Agreed?"
"Agreed," Chandler said.
"Agreed," Joey said.
They went back to the living room.
The party had found its second wind — the dinner plates cleared, people redistributed into smaller conversations, the specific ease of a gathering that had passed the formal portion and arrived at the comfortable part.
Jack was telling a story to Lola and Jean that appeared to involve a driving incident in New Jersey in 1974, and both women were laughing in the specific way of people who are genuinely amused rather than being polite. Ross had found his way to the kitchen to help Monica with something and they were doing the quiet sibling thing they did sometimes, working alongside each other without needing to talk.
Chandler sat back down next to Janice.
Andrew watched him make the decision in real time — the choice to be present rather than manage, to let himself be exactly where he was rather than building the exit. It was a small thing. It was also not a small thing.
Janice said something that made Chandler laugh — the real one, surprised out of him, the laugh that arrived before the deflection could.
Andrew turned away to give it some privacy.
Monica found him at nine-thirty, standing near the window looking at the street.
"Ursula," she said.
"I know," he said.
"She's Phoebe's sister."
"I know that too."
"Why is she here, Andrew." It wasn't quite a question.
He thought about how to explain it — the Chandler-and-Joey situation, the guilt, the avoidance, the idea that meeting the actual person would resolve something that had been sitting wrong for weeks. It was true and it was also not the complete truth, because the complete truth included that he'd thought it would be interesting, which was harder to justify.
"Unfinished business," he said. "It's handled now."
Monica looked at him with the expression she wore when she was deciding whether to press something.
"Is my party going to end normally?" she said.
"Yes," he said.
"Promise me."
"I promise."
She held his gaze for another moment, then exhaled and accepted it.
"Good," she said. "Because my mother told me the chicken was very good."
Andrew smiled. "I heard."
"She said it twice," Monica said, with the specific quality of someone holding something carefully. "She doesn't say things twice."
"No," he said. "She doesn't."
Monica looked at the room — her room, her people, her birthday — with the expression of someone who had wanted something for a long time and was standing inside it and trying to stay present enough to feel it properly.
"Thank you," she said. "For the thing with my dad. Whatever you said to him."
"I just told him what I saw," Andrew said. "He did the rest."
She nodded slowly. Then she went back to her guests.
[Goal Tracker]
PS 500 → 1 Bonus Chapter
Reviews 10 → 1 Bonus Chapter
If you enjoyed it, consider a review.
P1treon Soulforger has 20+advance chapters